The M&S Case followed again: C-322/11 K
K, a Finnish taxpayer, sought to deduct losses that were incurred in respect of the transfer of immovable property in France from taxable shares that were transferred in Finland.
Read More
Transfer of Pensions – HMRC Guidance responding to the ROSIIP GLO
HMRC will not raise assessments from transfers from a registered pension scheme to an overseas scheme provided that 1) the transfer took place before 24 September 2008; and 2) the scheme was included on the list as a QROPS when the transfer took place (or at a time reasonably proximate to the transfer). This is subject to an obvious proviso in case of dishonesty, abuse, artificiality, etc.
Read More
Autumn Statement
Deep within the press notices accompanying both the budget and pre-budget review has in the past been a likely place to announce retrospective changes limiting claims for the recovery of tax or changes responding to ECJ decisions. Examples include the changes following Cadbury Schweppes, Marks and Spencer and DMG. The notices accompanying today's statement however contained no such announcements of legislative changes affecting EU tax claims. The Chancellor did announce a number of measures relevant to cross border groups to be included in Finance Bill 2014 which have immediate effect.
Read More
Prudential, dividend tax and compensation for breach of EU law
Under the credit system in place before 2009, non-resident dividend income from the EU/EEA is not to be regarded as exempt but as taxable with credit, in addition to withholding tax, for the higher of the tax actually paid on the profits or the nominal (statutory) rate of the jurisdiction of the dividend paying company. The same outcome applies where the investment is below a controlling interest for dividends from all jurisdictions outside the EU/EEA as well. Where possible, tax returns must be amended to claim the enhanced credit, rather than to show the non-resident income as exempt. The claimants are entitled to compound interest on overpaid tax. HMRC’s ‘change of position’ defence is contrary to EU law. Originally printed in Tax Journal on 1 Nov 2013.
Read More
UK taxpayers should amend open returns to benefit from High Court Prudential ruling
UK tax payers will need to amend any open returns to show foreign portfolio income as carrying a tax credit following the England and Wales High Court's ruling in the Prudential case last week. Nicola Hine, of Joseph Hage Aaronson, the firm acting for the claimants in the case, explains why the judgment should be welcomed by tax payers with claims for interest on overpaid tax. Originally printed in International Tax Review Premium, 31 October 2013.
Read More
Advocate General opinion in FII GLO encourages claimants
The Franked Investment Income Group Litigation (FII GLO) concerning claimants’ rights to recover overcharged tax from HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) has been batted back and forth between the UK courts and the European Court of Justice (ECJ) since 2006. Philippe Freund explains why an Advocate General’s opinion on the third reference to the ECJ has given taxpayers cause to be optimistic. Originally printed in International Tax Review Premium, 1 October 2013.
Read More
Adviser Q&A: AG’s opinion in FII Test Claimants
The advocate general’s opinion on Test Claimants in the FII Group Litigation v HMRC (Case C-362/12) was delivered on 5 September. Simon Whitehead takes a look. Originally printed in Tax Journal, 13 September 2013.
Read More
Belgium notional interest deduction regime contrary to EU law
The Court concluded that the regime discouraged a Belgian company from carrying out its activity through a permanent establishment situated in another state and, consequently, amounted to a breach of the freedom of establishment in Article 49 TFEU.
Read More
Exit Taxes
The CJEU, following recent case law, concluded that the Danish rules on exit taxation of cross-border transfers of assets within a company are contrary to the freedom of establishment within the meaning of Article 49 TFEU.
Read More
Portfolio Dividend Claims: High Court Trial Concludes
The hearing dealt with issues arising out of corporation tax charges on foreign-source portfolio dividends, ACT charges on their onward payment and a number of issues specific to life assurance and pension business, as well as remedies, including the availability of compound interest, and HMRC’s contention that unlawful tax paid under a mistake could not be recovered where the UK had applied its tax revenues against government expenditure (“the change of position” defence). Judgment has been reserved.
Read More