C-533/16 – Volkswagen AG wins preliminary ruling on ‘right to deduct VAT’
This judgment relates to the proceedings between Volkswagen AG and the Finance Directorate of the Slovak Republic. The dispute arose after a partial refusal by the Finance Directorate of the Slovak Republic of an application for a refundof value added tax (‘VAT’), charged several years after the initial delivery of the supplied goods to Volkswagen AG.
The Slovak government argued that the 5 year limitation period (Law No 511/1992 on Tax Administration, ‘The Tax Code’), starting from the date of delivery of the goods, had already expired when the application for deduction was made on 1 July 2011.
The legal context asks whether the fixing of the starting date of the five year limitation period is compatible with EU law on the common system of value added tax. While current EU law on the common system of value added tax holds that the ‘right to deduct’ (Article 167 of Directive 2006/112) is an integral part of the VAT scheme, the ‘right to deduct’ is also subject to substantive requirements or conditions (judgment of 19 October 2017, Paper Consult, C-101/16, paragraph 38).
The CJEU found that EU law must be interpreted to preclude national legislation of a Member State in circumstances, such as the main proceedings, when the exercise of the right to claim a refund expired before the VAT tax was charged and an application for a refund was submitted.
This article appears in the JHA March 2018 Tax Newsletter, which also features:
- Danish Beneficial Ownership Cases – AG’s Opinions Support the Taxpayers
- EU Council publishes proposal for draft Directive (DAC6) to prevent potentially aggressive cross-border tax planning
As announced in July of last year, the 2020 Budget introduces a new deferred payment plan option for Corporation Tax charged on profits or gains arising from certain transactions between UK companies and EEA companies of the same group of companies.
Reversal of Inverclyde
The 2020 Budget announced provisions to reverse last year’s FTT decision in Inverclyde. In that case, HMRC denied the appellant LLPs’ claims for Business Property Renovation Allowance on the basis that the LLPs did not carry on a business with a view to a profit.
HMRC nudge letters
HMRC continues to fight the good fight in its quest to cut down on tax avoidance and have recently been issuing further “nudge” letters to taxpayers who may have an income source or assets producing gains overseas and consequently an undisclosed outstanding UK tax liability.
ExxonMobil: FTT Decision Released
The FTT decision in Esso Exploration and Production UK Limited and others v HMRC, which relates to pre-2006 claims for Cross Border Group Relief, has now been released.