JHA LLP | London Tax Disputes Solicitors & Barristers

Unjust Enrichment Defence Compatible with Equal Treatment

02 February 2014

Author: JHA

Reed Employment Ltd v HMRC [2014] EWCA Civ 32

By Alice McDonald

Section 3 of the Finance Act (No.2) 2005 introduced an unjust enrichment defence against claims for repayment of VAT. This defence came into force on 26 May 2005. In 2009, and therefore following the introduction of section 3, the claimant filed repayment claims which had arisen in years before the defence came into force. HMRC relied upon the defence and refused to make repayments. The claimant challenged the application of the defence to the pre 2005 claims on the basis that the defence was incompatible with the EU law principle of equal treatment.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. It found that the defence introduced in section 3 did not breach EU law and that HMRC could rely upon it.

This article appears in the JHA January 2014 Tax Newsletter, which also features:

FII and Dividend Tax Update
Tax Credit Claims Made Out Of Time by Alice McDonald
Exit Taxes by Amita Chohan

You can download the complete newsletter as a PDF below:

January 2014 – Tax Newsletter

Return to List of Articles by UK Lawyers on Tax Disputes, Tax Litigation, HMRC Tax Appeal

Return to Listings

Left Button on Tax Dispute & Tax Litigation Lawyers in London

Our Insights

Insights from UK Tax Dispute Lawyers & HMRC Tax litigation

Search and Seizure

Helen McGhee TEP, Elizabeth Dean and Megan Durnford consider HMRC’s ever-expanding criminal investigation powers

UT considers taxpayer’s application for permanent anonymity and third-party disclosure request (HMRC v The Taxpayer and Others)

The Upper Tribunal (UT) rejected a taxpayer’s application for permanent anonymity, following the taxpayer's decision to withdraw their substantive appeal with the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT). The UT further granted a third party limited access to the FTT’s previous case management decision. The UT’s decision emphasises the importance placed on open justice and highlights the court and tribunals’ reluctance to permit anonymity in litigation.

PRIVATE CIENT BUDGET UPDATE

The new rules are complex and what follows is an overview. The non dom changes will be effective from 6 April 2025. No changes have been made to the statutory residence test (SRT) effective for UK tax purposes from tax year 2013/14 onwards (prior to then the common law determined UK residence status for tax purposes).

THE END OF THE REMITTANCE BASIS AND THE TWO TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS

Tax year 2024/25 (the current year) marks the last year that eligible individuals will be able to make a remittance basis claim. From 2025/26 the remittance basis will be replaced with the 4-year FIG regime. There is no amnesty for existing foreign income and gains that were previously sheltered by the remittance basis regime and have not yet been taxed. Any remittance to the UK after 5 April 2025 will be subject to taxation just as it was before, albeit the new legislation:

REVIEW OF ANTI-AVOIDANCE LEGISLATION

A 29 July 2024 government policy paper announced that there would be a review of the offshore anti-avoidance legislation.

Right Button on Tax Dispute & Tax Litigation Lawyers in London

View Our Insights